Earn-Out Clauses in M&A Transactions: Flexibility for Buyers and Sellers

The purchase price is regularly one of the most difficult negotiation points in a business acquisition. Sellers often orient themselves to past successes and future growth opportunities of their business. Buyers typically assess future prospects more cautiously and want to limit the risk of an overly optimistic business valuation.

Especially when expectations about business value and growth opportunities diverge, an earn-out clause can provide the decisive breakthrough in negotiations. It enables the parties to make a portion of the purchase price dependent on the actual economic performance of the business after closing of the transaction and is therefore often the critical compromise to bridge differing purchase price expectations.

Earn-out clauses are now an established instrument of purchase price structuring in the M&A sector. A large proportion of business acquisition agreements now include earn-out arrangements. They create a balance between the interests of buyer and seller and enable transactions that would not have been concluded without a variable purchase price component.

What Is an Earn-Out?

An earn-out is a variable purchase price component in a business acquisition. In addition to a fixed base purchase price, the parties agree that the seller receives an additional variable amount if the business achieves certain (economic) targets within a defined period. In practice, this variable amount can constitute a significant portion of the total purchase price.

The specific structure of an earn-out depends on the particular characteristics of each transaction. In practice, the variable purchase price is based particularly on

• economic metrics such as revenue, EBIT, or EBITDA,
• operational milestones, such as a successful product launch, production figures, or obtaining regulatory approval,
• the conclusion of significant customer or supplier contracts.

The variable purchase price can be paid as a one-time payment or distributed over several fiscal years. In the latter case, the earn-out payment is regularly based on the development of the agreed metrics and criteria in the individual fiscal years.

When Are Earn-Out Clauses Particularly Useful?

Earn-outs are used particularly when business value is difficult to determine reliably. They help bridge valuation uncertainties and reconcile differing expectations of the contracting parties regarding the future development of the business.

Typical use cases are:

• businesses with high growth potential,
• start-ups and technology companies,
• innovative business models with still difficult-to-forecast returns, or
• volatile markets or economically uncertain conditions.

Opportunities and Risks

Earn-out clauses offer significant advantages for both buyers and sellers.

From the buyer’s perspective:

• Lower immediate financing requirement,
• alignment of purchase price with actual economic success,
• lower risk of business overvaluation.

From the seller’s perspective:

• Opportunity for a higher total purchase price,
• participation in positive business development even after the sale,
• better conditions for a successful contract conclusion.

The greatest challenge, however, often begins only after closing. At this point, the buyer makes the essential business decisions, while the amount of the earn-out continues to depend on the economic performance of the business. Investments, changes in accounting or business policy, or intra-group restructurings can influence the relevant metrics and thus have direct effects on the variable purchase price.

To avoid later disputes, the parties should clearly regulate in particular

• which metrics are relevant and how they are calculated,
• according to which accounting principles the calculation is performed,
• which actions the buyer may take without the seller’s consent during the earn-out period,
• what information and control rights the seller has,
• how disagreements about the calculation of the earn-out are resolved.

In practice, it frequently becomes apparent that the economic concept of an earn-out is not problematic, but rather a clear and comprehensive contractual structure.

Conclusion

Earn-out clauses are now an integral part of M&A practice. They make it possible to bridge differing expectations about business value and successfully conclude transactions even when the future development of the business is still subject to uncertainties.

For an earn-out to fulfill its economic purpose, balanced and precise contract design is critical. The more clearly the economic targets, calculation mechanisms, and the rights and obligations of the parties are regulated, the lower the risk of later disputes. A carefully drafted earn-out clause therefore not only creates legal certainty, but also frequently contributes significantly to the long-term success of the transaction.

From the newsletter
“Corporate Law, Deals & Capital Markets” Subscribe to the newsletter
here