You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. Please enable scripts and reload this page.
Home
Deutsch
|
English
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Worldwide
It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. Please turn on JavaScript and try again.
✕
Germany
Ansbach
Bayreuth
Berlin
Bielefeld
Chemnitz
Cologne
Dortmund
Dresden
Eschborn
Fuerth
Hamburg
Hanover
Herford
Hof
Jena
Mettlach
Munich
Nuremberg
Plauen
Regensburg
Selb
Stuttgart
Ulm
Worldwide
Algeria
Angola
Argentina
Australia
Austria
Azerbaijan
Bahrain
Belarus
Belgium
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Botswana
Brazil
Bulgaria
Cambodia
Canada
Chile
China
Colombia
Costa Rica
Croatia
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
Ecuador
Egypt
Estonia
Ethiopia
Finland
France
Georgia
Germany
Ghana
Greece
Hong Kong (S.A.R.)
Hungary
India
Indonesia
Ireland
Italy
Japan
Kazakhstan
Kenya
Kuwait
Latvia
Libya
Liechtenstein
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Malaysia
Malta
Mauritius
Mexico
Moldova
Mongolia
Morocco
Mozambique
Myanmar
Namibia
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nigeria
North Macedonia
Norway
Oman
Pakistan
Paraguay
Peru
Philippines
Poland
Portugal
Qatar
Romania
Saudi Arabia
Serbia
Singapore
Slovakia
Slovenia
South Africa
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Taiwan
Tajikistan
Tanzania
Thailand
Tunisia
Turkey
Uganda
Ukraine
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom
Uruguay
USA
Uzbekistan
Vietnam
Zambia
Own offices of Rödl & Partner
German Professional Services Alliance -
GPSA
(Colours appear during mouseover)
We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our
data privacy statement
.
Insights
Services
Expertise from a single source
Rödl & Partner is excellently positioned with each individual service line. Based on this and using our interdisciplinary skills we guarantee our clients a special added value from the seamless combination of the services we provide.
Our service lines
As attorneys, tax advisers, management and IT consultants and auditors, we are present with 116 own offices in 50 countries. Worldwide, our clients trust our around 6,000 colleagues.
Legal advisory
Tax consulting
Audit services
Management and IT consulting
Business Process Outsourcing
Interdisciplinary services
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
The strength of Rödl & Partner lies in comprehensive advisory by interdisciplinary teams not only in the case of transaction advisory, nationally and internationally in 116 locations worldwide.
Succession advisory
Rödl & Partner assists you with organising and implementing company succession solutions in line with your expectations, wishes and needs. In this process, we provide comprehensive legal, tax and business advisory.
Mergers & Acquisitions
Stay informed
The newsletter Corporate Law, Deals & Capital Markets informs you every month about current topics in the areas of corporate law, M&A and capital markets law.
Completed deals
Transaction advisory is interdisciplinary teamwork. We are committed to being one of the leading M&A advisors for the German Mittelstand.
Who we advise
Media
Newsletters
Stay informed on the latest developments with our comprehensive international newsletters, from Africa to Vietnam.
Virtual reality tours
Get to know us virtually and experience our working atmosphere and core brand values up close. We offer you exciting insights into the world of Rödl & Partner by using 360 degree technology.
Virtual reality tours
Publications
Good to know
Newsletters
Brochures
Investment guides
Books
Download centre
Releases
Completed deals
Media contacts
Facts and figures
About us
Entrepreneurial spirit and values
Our brand does not only consist of a logo, but also defines our unique selling propositions and our business model through our brand DNA.
Factbook
We will introduce ourselves and take you to the core of our professional services firm, tell you where we come from, how we think, how we feel, and communicate our vision of the future. Together with you.
Facts and figures
Sustainability
Entrepreneurial spirit and values
Factbook
Managing Partners
Founder Dr. Bernd Rödl
Locations worldwide
Social responsibility
Project Fundus
Read more about the previous projects of the Rödl Employee Fund for Children’s Aid in our project fund.
Rödl Employee Fund for Children’s Aid
Partner cities: Kharkiv-Nuremberg
Family and career
Awards
Compliance & Incident Reporting System
Digital Agenda
Careers
Insights
The new right to repair: sustainably innovative or in need of repair?
ASEAN
ASEAN Forum
Digital Agenda
E-Invoicing
Indonesia Strategy Forum
Insights
Currently selected
Recent
Alle Kolumnen
Altersvorsorge
Antitrust Law
AOA
Artikelserie im OMV Fokus
ASEAN
Assurance & IT in der Gesundheits- und Sozialwirtschaft
Aufsichtsrecht
Außenwirtschaft und Zoll
BilRUG und weitere Reformen
International Expert Roundtable
The new right to repair: sustainably innovative or in need of repair?
Page Content
published on 23 February 2024 | reading time approx. 4 minutes
The premature discarding of consumer goods generates around 35 million tons of waste in the EU every year, primarily electronic waste, as well as 261 million tons of CO2 emissions. At the same time, 30 million tons of resources remain economically unused, especially valuable metals such as copper, aluminum, zinc and lithium. Consumers who replace products instead of repairing them incur additional costs of around EUR 12 billion per year. According to a study by the European Commission, 77% of the EU population would prefer a repair to a new purchase. However, this often fails due to suboptimal repair conditions or high repair costs. This is now set to change.
Further components of the Green Deal »
Which products are covered by the directive? »
What does the right to repair entail? »
Who is obliged to repair? »
How do I get a repair? »
Next steps »
Conclusion»
Further components of the Green Deal
At the beginning of February, the Council and the EU Parliament reached a provisional agreement on the so-called “Directive on the promotion of repair of goods”, which has been circulating in the media under the catchphrase “right to repair” and could ensure greater sustainability in the future. This agreement is based on a proposal presented by the EU Commission almost a year ago (COM(2023) 155 final, 2023/0083 (COD) of 22.3.2023, available at
resource.html (europa.eu))
.
The right to repair proposal complements EU initiatives on eco-design and consumer empowerment for the green transition. The aim is to prevent the premature discarding of goods by making access to repair services simpler, faster, more transparent and more attractive. This should secure jobs, promote more sustainable business models and limit dependence on raw materials from abroad.
Which products are covered by the directive?
The provisional agreement so far only covers products for which repairability requirements have been defined in EU regulations. This currently mainly includes “white goods” such as (household) washing machines, dryers, dishwashers, refrigerators, but also smartphones, tablets, electronic displays, servers, data storage devices and vacuum cleaners.
Against the backdrop of the ambitious goal of a climate-neutral domestic market by 2050, however, it can be assumed that this list will expand significantly. Companies are therefore well advised to monitor further developments and prepare accordingly.
W
hat does the right to repair entail?
According to the draft directive, the member states must ensure that the manufacturers of the aforementioned goods repair them at the request of a consumer even after the warranty period has expired, within a reasonable period and at a reasonable price. Otherwise, there would be a risk that the consumer would, purely factually, prefer to buy a new product rather than having it repaired.
MEPs also propose extending the warranty period by one year from the date of repair if consumers opt for a repair instead of a replacement delivery in the event of a defect. To make repairing more attractive than replacing, manufacturers should make loaner devices available for the duration of the repair.
The manufacturer may subcontract repairs in order to fulfill its repair obligation. It does not apply to goods that cannot be repaired. However, the draft does not specify when this is the case. The directive also does not define a binding quality standard for repairs. If a product can no longer be repaired, the possibility of offering an already repaired product instead should be considered.
Who is obliged to repair?
The manufacturer is generally obliged to repair the product. If the manufacturer is based outside the EU, the authorized representative, the importer or even the dealer of such a product may be liable for repairs, similar to the provisions of product liability law.
How do I get a repair?
The draft directive provides for
extensive information
obligations with regard to the essential characteristics of the repair service and the identity of the repair business.
In order to reduce the administrative burden for repairers (especially small ones),
a standardized European form for repair information
is to be used. If this is used, the repairers are bound by the conditions specified therein. The form must be made available free of charge, although consumers may be asked to bear the costs of the diagnostic service.
Finally, there are also plans to create a
European “match-making” repair platform
to make it possible to contact repair service providers in the consumer's region across borders.
Next steps
The draft directive still has to be approved and formally adopted by both sides. It is expected to be adopted shortly. The EU member states will then have a period of 18 months to transpose the directive into national law. In this respect, regulation in Germany would probably have to take place in the second half of 2025.
Full harmonization is envisaged, i.e. the member states may not maintain or issue any regulations that deviate from this directive.
Conclusion
From a business perspective, the draft must be viewed critically. On the one hand
it extends the manufacturer's responsibility immensely, on the other hand it leaves many questions unanswered - both factual and legal. For example, it does not specify how long repairs must be made possible, nor how long the manufacturer must keep spare parts in stock. The willingness of companies to disclose repair information will also reach its limits where the disclosure of secret know-how is involved. According to the current provisions of the German Trade Secrets Act, so-called reverse engineering to obtain technical information about the mode of action of a product is generally permitted, but in the end the person who wants to repair a product will need further information or, for example, remote access to a smart product. However, according to the recently updated cyber security requirements, smart products in particular should be even more protected against access. It is also still disputed when the sale of re-filed and re-furbed products is permissible and when it constitutes a trademark or patent infringement. The draft leaves open how this tension between IP rights, consumer protection and environmental protection is to be resolved. Finally, it is questionable how repairs are to be offered at reasonable prices if manufacturers first have to set up the associated logistics.
It remains to be seen to what extent the right to repair will actually be exercised and whether it can create the desired incentive for greater sustainability. Nevertheless, manufacturers will have to deal with it, not least in order to meet their own climate targets and avoid a possible fine, which the directive also prefers.
From the Newsletter
Contact
Ines Maier, LL.M.
Associate Partner
+49 911 9193 1605
Send inquiry
How we can help
ESG from a legal perspective
Product Lifecycle
Sustainability Services
Turn on more accessible mode
Turn off more accessible mode
Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Turn off Animations
Turn on Animations
Deutschland
Weltweit
Search
Menu