You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. Please enable scripts and reload this page.
Home
Deutsch
|
English
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Rödl & Partner opens new office in Waterloo, Canada |
Worldwide
It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. Please turn on JavaScript and try again.
✕
Germany
Ansbach
Bayreuth
Berlin
Bielefeld
Chemnitz
Cologne
Dortmund
Dresden
Eschborn
Fuerth
Hamburg
Hanover
Herford
Hof
Jena
Mettlach
Munich
Nuremberg
Plauen
Regensburg
Selb
Stuttgart
Ulm
Worldwide
Algeria
Angola
Argentina
Australia
Austria
Azerbaijan
Bahrain
Belarus
Belgium
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Botswana
Brazil
Bulgaria
Cambodia
Canada
Chile
China
Colombia
Costa Rica
Croatia
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
Ecuador
Egypt
Estonia
Ethiopia
Finland
France
Georgia
Germany
Ghana
Greece
Hong Kong (S.A.R.)
Hungary
India
Indonesia
Ireland
Italy
Japan
Kazakhstan
Kenya
Kuwait
Latvia
Libya
Liechtenstein
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Malaysia
Malta
Mauritius
Mexico
Moldova
Mongolia
Morocco
Mozambique
Myanmar
Namibia
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nigeria
North Macedonia
Norway
Oman
Pakistan
Paraguay
Peru
Philippines
Poland
Portugal
Qatar
Romania
Saudi Arabia
Serbia
Singapore
Slovakia
Slovenia
South Africa
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Taiwan
Tajikistan
Tanzania
Thailand
Tunisia
Turkey
Uganda
Ukraine
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom
Uruguay
USA
Uzbekistan
Vietnam
Zambia
Own offices of Rödl & Partner
German Professional Services Alliance -
GPSA
(Colours appear during mouseover)
We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our
data privacy statement
.
Insights
Services
Expertise from a single source
Rödl & Partner is excellently positioned with each individual service line. Based on this and using our interdisciplinary skills we guarantee our clients a special added value from the seamless combination of the services we provide.
Our service lines
As attorneys, tax advisers, management and IT consultants and auditors, we are present with 116 own offices in 50 countries. Worldwide, our clients trust our around 6,000 colleagues.
Legal advisory
Tax consulting
Audit services
Management and IT consulting
Business Process Outsourcing
Interdisciplinary services
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
The strength of Rödl & Partner lies in comprehensive advisory by interdisciplinary teams not only in the case of transaction advisory, nationally and internationally in 116 locations worldwide.
Succession advisory
Rödl & Partner assists you with organising and implementing company succession solutions in line with your expectations, wishes and needs. In this process, we provide comprehensive legal, tax and business advisory.
Mergers & Acquisitions
Stay informed
The newsletter Corporate Law, Deals & Capital Markets informs you every month about current topics in the areas of corporate law, M&A and capital markets law.
Completed deals
Transaction advisory is interdisciplinary teamwork. We are committed to being one of the leading M&A advisors for the German Mittelstand.
Who we advise
Media
Newsletters
Stay informed on the latest developments with our comprehensive international newsletters, from Africa to Vietnam.
Virtual reality tours
Get to know us virtually and experience our working atmosphere and core brand values up close. We offer you exciting insights into the world of Rödl & Partner by using 360 degree technology.
Virtual reality tours
Publications
Good to know
Newsletters
Brochures
Investment guides
Books
Download centre
Releases
Completed deals
Media contacts
Facts and figures
About us
Entrepreneurial spirit and values
Our brand does not only consist of a logo, but also defines our unique selling propositions and our business model through our brand DNA.
Factbook
We will introduce ourselves and take you to the core of our professional services firm, tell you where we come from, how we think, how we feel, and communicate our vision of the future. Together with you.
Facts and figures
Sustainability
Entrepreneurial spirit and values
Factbook
Managing Partners
Founder Dr. Bernd Rödl
Locations worldwide
Social responsibility
Project Fundus
Read more about the previous projects of the Rödl Employee Fund for Children’s Aid in our project fund.
Rödl Employee Fund for Children’s Aid
Partner cities: Kharkiv-Nuremberg
Family and career
Awards
Compliance & Incident Reporting System
Digital Agenda
Careers
Insights
Evaluating sustainability: ESG ratings – what's behind them?
ASEAN
ASEAN Forum
Digital Agenda
E-Invoicing
Indonesia Strategy Forum
Insights
Currently selected
Recent
Alle Kolumnen
Altersvorsorge
Antitrust Law
AOA
Artikelserie im OMV Fokus
ASEAN
Assurance & IT in der Gesundheits- und Sozialwirtschaft
Aufsichtsrecht
Außenwirtschaft und Zoll
BilRUG und weitere Reformen
International Expert Roundtable
Evaluating sustainability: ESG ratings – what's behind them?
Page Content
published on 17 november 2023 | reading time approx. 4 minutes
Sustainability is more present than ever, with a growing number of companies committing to more sustainable business practices, ranging from reducing CO2 emissions to improving working conditions for employees. But what is sustainable and what is not is difficult to recognize from an external perspective. Various sustainability standards, such as the ESRS, GRI, DNK and EU Taxonomy, can be used to determine a company's own sustainability performance. However, sustainability rating agencies can also help to classify different companies.
How do ratings differ from one another?
Insights into ESG rating agencies
Outlook: challenges and benefits
External rating agencies assess companies based on ESG-relevant key figures, risk and performance indicators, such as emissions to air, soil and water, the appropriate treatment of employees and sustainable business practices. These are aimed at a large number of stakeholders but are currently mainly used by investors and fund managers, as increasing attention is being paid to ecological, social and corporate policy aspects in the context of the financial market.
Sustainability ratings can be used by companies and stakeholders to achieve a classification in the market. As there are various sustainability rating providers and methods of rating creation, the different types are examined in more detail below.
How do Ratings differ from one another?
The methods used to produce ESG ratings vary greatly depending on the provider and are therefore difficult to compare. The first difference lies in the commissioning of the ratings. There are ratings that are commissioned and paid for by companies and those that are not commissioned by companies but select the companies they rate on the basis of certain criteria. The advantage of commissioned ratings is that internal information to which the public does not have access can also be evaluated. The problem with non-commissioned ratings, on the other hand, is the lack of diversity of information, as only public sources can be used. A mixture results from cooperative ratings, which are not commissioned and therefore not paid for. They only work if the company cooperates with the rating agency and makes these internal sources available.
There are also differences in the analysis and evaluation processes. The latter can be carried out by algorithms or purely manually. Data sources include sustainability reports prepared by the company itself, news or special events, external reports and, where applicable, internal reports.
Insight into ESG Rating Agencies
The major differences in the methods used by rating agencies and the associated lack of transparency are also well known in the EU. In particular, the quality and reliability of ratings should be ensured through authorization and supervision by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA).
As the ESG rating market is highly dynamic and complex, the international reputation of the rating agencies is an important criterion for investors. There are a large number of different rating agencies internationally and throughout the EU. The following three rating agencies have the largest market share:
Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI)
Sustainalytics
Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS)
MSCI
evaluates companies primarily in terms of their ESG risks and how well they are managed compared to their competitors. The classification is divided into “AAA-AA” - “LEADER”, “A-BB” - “AVERAGE” and “B-CCC” - “LAGGARD”.
When assessing companies,
Sustainalytics
focuses on weighing up financial risks. A distinction is made between different categories: “Manageable Risk” and “Unmanageable Risk”. Manageable risk is also broken down further and divided into managed risk and the management gap. The “management gap” is characterized by the fact that these are risks that could be managed but are not yet managed. Together with the “unmanageable risk”, this results in the “unmanaged risk”, i.e. the risk that is not managed. The final ESG risk rating is based on this.
Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS)
applies a wide range of around 100 rating criteria, including environmental management, climate change strategy and human rights. The rating system is in alphabetical order from “A+” to “D-”. ISS not only evaluates companies on their sustainability efforts, but also acts as a consultancy and proxy. As such, it exercises voting rights for large hedge funds and mutual funds and advises them on a wide range of sustainability issues (voting rights advisor).
Furthermore,
ecovadis
is also a widely used sustainability rating, which is primarily used in the SME sector. Ecovadis is a platform that supports companies in evaluating and improving their sustainability performance. The Ecovadis rating system analyzes various aspects using a questionnaire adapted to the industry, size and country of the company. The methodology used is in line with international standards. Based on these assessments, companies receive a sustainability score and customized suggestions for improvement.
Outlook: Challenges and Benefits
Even if the rating agencies take different approaches, there can be uniform benefits for the rated companies. Positive ESG ratings can be used to gain better access to green finance markets. ESG ratings form the basis for green financing instruments such as green bonds and sustainability-linked loans. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which are not normally checked for creditworthiness and sustainability without their own initiative, can also use ESG ratings to set themselves apart from their competitors and potentially benefit from better lending conditions. Investors are also paying more and more attention to potential sustainability risks and are incorporating sustainability aspects and positive ESG ratings into their investment decisions.
Furthermore, detailed ESG ratings can be used to evaluate internal sustainability processes and thus reduce sustainability risks in a targeted manner. Another advantage is the more credible communication of a company's own sustainability efforts to a wide range of stakeholders. ESG ratings can also be used by companies to gain an overview of the competition and to position themselves in the market.
ESG ratings should be taken seriously by companies, also as they are primarily aimed at investors. Due to the lack of transparency in the assessment methods of different rating agencies, companies with low data availability in the area of sustainability efforts may receive mixed ratings. The EU is already working on making ratings more transparent and therefore easier to use. The assessments of various rating providers should therefore be used in order to better classify the current market.
From the Newsletter
Contact
Christian Maier
Head of Sustainability Services, Partner
+49 711 7819 147 73
Send inquiry
FURTHER INFORMATION
Sustainability Services
Turn on more accessible mode
Turn off more accessible mode
Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Turn off Animations
Turn on Animations
Deutschland
Weltweit
Search
Menu